Ck3 clan vs feudal. Sep 9, 2020 · So I have a couple questions.

Ck3 clan vs feudal Worse for admin, as clan/feudal you get way more modifiers, i. The Clan government type is the muslim pendant to Feudalism, with its own rules. the only way fight byzantium is being tribal nation with 20k+ troops, if you are feudal like i form tsar russia only have 10k when byzantium have 15k and less income Totally 0/10 never become feudal again Byzantium probably has less income because of their current Basileus + wife + steward situation. I replaced the ruler of Transoxiana (Clan) with a Khurmazta custom character, yet I remained clan despite being a Zoroastrian faith. So, my key takeaways: Taxes and Levies from your vassals are scaled by their opinion of you. It seems to be mostly tied to religion. Here's how you make the decision to adopt Feudalism for your kingdom. However, these tips should make a playthrough easier. 32 votes, 12 comments. Technically there isn't a conversion feature, but there is a loophole. If Tribal is linear with a series of spikes, Feudal is exponential growth. I restarted at the decision point and now 6 generations later, the Empire is still united and Strong, even transferring both Empire titles to the heir. Republican vassals give 20% flat taxes to you. Sep 29, 2020 · We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Jul 12, 2022 · Absolute - Tribal with non-Tribal Lieges can settle, becoming Feudal or Clan, -30 opinion CK3 Tribal Expansion The need for Fabricated Claims is set aside if you play as a Tribal ruler, with you having access to Conquest Casus Belli. Sometimes you inherit vassals under the opposing medieval system, and as far as I know the only solution is completely revoking the Sep 18, 2020 · I just reformed a coptic egypt. Feudal vassals give 25% maximum but with big opinion penalties. What if i have a big money generating county or even duchy with focus on money, it seems like republican vassal would be more beneficial. Sep 5, 2020 · News About us Careers Join our playtests Media contactSocial Media Feb 6, 2024 · Playing as a tribal ruler in Crusader Kings 3 comes with its own set of unique challenges. There's nothing stopping you from doing that in a 1066 start. My question is when or how do you decide to transition from Tribal? Aside from limited City holding development, what are the Or if your heir somehow becomes the Feudal king of Sardinia & Corsica, on inheriting your realm they'll still be feudal. from innovations. England vs. I did notice that the buildings for feudal holdings seem to be a lot better overall. This isn't Civilization. Sep 9, 2020 · Here's how to become a feudal in Crusader Kings 3. While it's true that at the start nearly (?) all clan realms are Muslim and nearly (?) all Muslim realms are clan (or tribal), converting to or from Muslim doesn't change your government type in CK3. This makes it a lot less engaging to play from Sep 2, 2020 · I am playing the High Chiefdom of Ife which is Yoruba and tribal. Nov 6, 2022 · Do you want to become feudal in Crusader Kings 3? In this guide, we show you how to become one and what the requirements are. nexus. Muslim tribals get the choice to become a clan, and non-muslims get to become feudal. A small clan realm is much stronger than a small feudal realm. Clan is better mechanically but it can ruin rp. I like feudal the most as I always find myself f’ed in tribal, as I’m probably not that good at it, but clan government I don’t have any idea on how it works. . Jul 17, 2021 · I never got the option to choose between feudal and clan; only feudal. Jun 9, 2022 · Adds two decisions: 1) Clan player adopts feudalism (alongside their clan vassals, if any) 2) Feudal player forces clan vassals to adopt feudalism Republics, theocracies and tribes remain unaffected. Better than Feudal? In my point of view, yes, Clan allows to to be richer and have more levies than Feudal really easy, same casus belli of Tribal, that are the best casus belli in the game. Apr 3, 2021 · I think you guys are confusing something. The basic structure of lords and vassals plays the same, but your interactions with the lords under your rule may be somewhat different. When I first started playing ck3 and joined this sub, I remember someone saying that the clan government was the "worst in the game" and a lot of people agreeing. Jul 1, 2022 · The tribal system differs from its alternatives in a more distinct way. I don't mind waiting forever to go from tribe to feudal/clan, though the current version of CK3 does get quite tedious in peacetime. (The most likely what-if scenario would be, that one of the Italian republics going bigger and change to monarchy but their Nobles stay in the centers - sounds familiar, right? Nov 3, 2025 · Feudal Feudal governments can create new holdings and cadet branches, have access to the Crown Authority law, can apply Title Succession laws and can start a Co-Monarchy. If they love you (80+ opinion), they give really good contributions compared to feudal! 25% taxes and 60% levies. Everyone involved as Apostolic Christian the whole way through. Comparing Feudal vs Clan Vassals In Crusader Kings 3In this video we will be comparing clan and feudal vassals. I cover development, innovations, army building, and reforming into the f DawnTyrantEo How to Elective, and why Scandinavian Succession is Amazing; or- Tingmeet OP plz nerf CK3 Sep 10, 2020 · There are 3 main components to "Adopting Feudal Ways" as independent tribal Norse: 1) Absolute Tribal Authority, 2) Organized Faith, and 3) All Tribal Cultural Innovations. At least for feudal realms. Custom afghan characters start with clan government. It's a shame because I'm really enjoying most of the other aspects of clan governments, but it feels like they pull the game in the wrong direction. CK3 I've looked all over, but can't find the answer to this question. But I have seen where my vassal king went from feudal to clan. The initial objective and the way you move your family upward is by obtaining governorships (which are mostly duchy level titles). The Nomadic govERnment places you at the head of a mobile society. First, how is government type decided? I thought it was cultural, but my Pictish ruler is feudal while the Gaelic one was tribal and I'm pretty sure the Pict's aren't meant to be more advanced than the culture that's overtaking them. Is there some definite answer to the conditions? Wiki, posts CRUSADER KINGS PURCHASE LINK: https://www. I decided to start my CK3 playthroughs with some time in the earlier periods, and I'm wondering Why ever go tribal? The fact that you can spend renown to build military buildings, soldiers, and just declare war on anyone seems like a bit of an antithetical system for this game. You also don't have to deal with republican vassal offspring because they are chosen randomly after death on succession. If you want to convert you have to change the religion of your player heir to a non-Islamic, and land them at a castle holding before they inherit from you. It happened probably because the vassals to the king rebelled and rebel leader took the king title and kept his clan system. Moreover, your vassal limit is way higher, so it's arguably the intended end-game, paint-the-map government. Normally Being a Muslim playing as a clan is the default, although feudal is more stable but with a clan after a couple of banquets and hunts everyone will love you and generate more gold and soldiers :) You can't. Its based on opinion. Has anyone else had similar complaints? Or is there something I am missing that someone is willing to explain? May 2, 2025 · The Nomadic GovERnment: A New Way to Rule Forget the rigid hiERarchies of feudalism or the intricate webs of clan obligations. Sep 26, 2024 · I wish, the Devs would give us an Option, when landing a Character, which Government, they should get, because in my current Campaign, I have a Dynasty with only Feudal Rulers and I want them to stay Feudal, but the other Dynasties in my Realm including my own should of course, be administrative. The way to With the new additions to Clan having its own vassal contracts it can be fairly useful, but the only benefit it really gets over Feudal is nearby conquest Casus Belli against neighbors (which all Cultures unlock eventually, County and Ducal level). Went back to an older save and was wondering if I just attempted it improperly or it's not worth the switch as Tribal Scandinavia. CrusaderKings) submitted 4 hours ago * by Ok_Director_8355 Sep 4, 2020 · I have been playing for a while as a Finnish Tribe and after a long way I managed to reform the religion, get high crown authority and loads of money, however, right after I changed to Feudalism all the buildings I had in my cities just disappeared leaving me with a very small fraction of the money and levies I previously had, making me ofc a very vulnerable king. In this case, the levels of the Crown Authority are replaced by the Tribal Authority. Gold becomes more reliable to gain. That makes feudal then better. Sep 24, 2022 · Found this on Reddit, and it seems accurate based on my in-game experience (though I have more experience with Feudal than Clan) When reforming government from Tribal: Either have a culture with Arabic/Turkic/Iranian Heritage Or Have a faith considered Islamic Or Be a tribal ruler under a pre-existing Clan and Feudalize through your liege Feudal, and it iritates me because I find the Islamic world more interesting to play in typically. And all the titles I owned directly changed to Clan - counties, a duchy, several kingdoms. I want to go feudal because I believe it means I can get better units etc. Sep 17, 2020 · There are two types of Authority Laws: Tribal Authority Laws, exclusive to Tribal Government, and Crown Authority Laws, exclusive to Clan and Feudal Government. But he succeeded and now is set to conquer the Seljuk from the inside out. Sep 16, 2020 · Since the game in its current state is really wonky and severely ahistorical, I like to play as tribal nations and just build/form my own kingdom at a later date. At 0 opinion, a clan vassal gives 15% tax and 30% levy to their liege. Help? Edit: Answered! Clan is what you get when moving from Tribal AND have a Muslim faith (or liege has one). Yeah! I've ended up a clan main lol I find it so strange to play feudal anymore lmao. If I'm correct, 'clan' government is for non-tribal Muslims, while 'feudal' government is for non-tribal Christians. Usually its 10%. Due to that and the fact that after all this time I don't understand the mechanics behind what decides whats fuedal or clans and changing between the two, I have never played as a clan (I've played in europe and just started playing Jun 12, 2024 · Ok, not much has been said about how a Feudal or Clan government becomes an Admin empire, so what I say here could be completely irrelevant to the final product. facebook:more Oct 10, 2024 · Feudal is piss poor governing style compared to Administrative. Tribal governments are very different compared to the other two, especially in how limited The obligations of clan vassals depend on their opinion of their liege. In reality you had even many local shades of hereditary rule, i. com Jun 7, 2022 · Unlike the Feudal governments of Europe, Middle-Eastern rulers in Crusader Kings 3 tend to use the Clan government type. Is It really only possible to play as a clan government when playing as a Muslim dynasty? Do I really need to convert back to my original African religion/Christianity, adopt feudal ways, and then convert back? Feb 27, 2024 · Clan to feudal. However, I noticed that some Turkic cultures are allowed to become Clan regardless of Covering running a clan, making money with tax collectors, house unity, succession, vassal management, tax decrees game play style, difference with feudal government, and more! Oct 16, 2024 · It applies the 50% to the 25% base of extortionate rates, so it becomes a 37. Second, how do I advance to Feudalism if I'm already feudal? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Alliances are much more important here, not only because of wars, but with you dont have alliances with great clans they will receive -30 with you. Think of it as another way to play, like the Clan government type. 5% base obligation. I try and be Nov 13, 2025 · Feudal Feudal governments can create new holdings and cadet branches, have access to the Crown Authority law, can apply Title Succession laws and can start a Co-Monarchy. If you are Clan, you cannot become Feudal. Nov 13, 2023 · Im trying to play the new dlc but I cant without being clan government. AI rulers will never take this decision. Clan has conquest casus beli, but I personally find it more fun to find a person with a claim and scheme around it. Tribal is busted right now. Feudalism provides more gold and better bonuses for units in the long run. So how am I supposed to do that from feudal??? I wish Paradox would make switching governments easier, at least tribal all you gotta do is leave all feudal lands to someone else, even if eventually all tribal land is gone its possible to convert. Feudal, though the right circumstances do make the tribal -> feudal pipeline a fun and interesting challenge to catch up to your neighbors with. However, I've noticed now that the option to 'adopt feudal ways' in the descions tab has changed to 'adopt clan ways'. As i see it all muslims can become calns and all non-muslims simply become feudal, but jewish rulers can also be clans as i noticed. Administrative could potentially be Nov 13, 2023 · Im trying to play the new dlc but I cant without being clan government. Feudal you have contracts which can be modified to allow the liege to focus mainly on taxes or levies. But I've not figured out how to go to clan government. Vassals were untouched - those which had been Feudal before remain Feudal, those which were Clan, Clan. Should I stick with High Partition or go with elective, so that I can (hopefully) choose my heir? In this new series I will be explaining certain mechanics in CK3 as well as providing tips and tricks as to how best to utilise them so your games can be suc Sep 27, 2023 · Just wondering if there's a way I haven't discovered, to change a clan vassal contract to fuedal (or vice versa). Apr 24, 2025 · CK3 Is there any reason to not rush feudal? Or not go feudal and just stay tribal? (self. If you use a custom character, you will have to start with a European culture that has Feudal culture by default, then convert on game start. They really need to add the option to convert to feudal from clan. Now, if the clan vassal has a +50 opinion of their liege then their contribution is 20% tax and 45. Hacemos una pequeña comparacion entre el contrato feudal y clan. So, even at 0 opinion clan vassals are better than feudal vassals. Ultimately, is it better to convert to Feudal or stay Tribal ? Thank you! Finally, the feudal simply has more gameplay features and complexity than clan with different contract types and reliance on claims for wars. If the upcoming LOP changes to clan turn out to be very strong, you'll play a multiplayer game and see the Catholic King of France with clan government. However, clan has neither of these and just solely replies on opinion. I really think ck3 shines when the spotlight is on fewer characters. Wales vs. To go from tribal to feudal is spelled out pretty clearly in game. This is done through education and use of the lifestyle perks in Feb 5, 2024 · Occupying the middle ground of Crusader Kings 3 between Tribes and Feudal systems, Clans can become extremely powerful with the help of these tips. Dev also only gives tribal gov't supply bonuses but gives feudal gov't and clan gov't income and levies as well. Sep 8, 2020 · At some point while playing Crusader Kings 3, you'll want to switch from Tribal to Feudal government. One of the drawbacks of administrative government is that you get a lot less levies than with Feudal government, even from governors with a Military Theme (though levies aren't very good anyway). May 2, 2025 · Now that we have an additional noamdic government on top of admin government, we have more and more non-nomadic government options now. paradoxwikis. 25% levy. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Which is a better government to become as a tribe: feudal or clan? What are the See full list on ck3. Subsequent levels of Tribal Authority: Level 1: opinion of direct vassals 10; Level 2: the possibility of imprisoning a character, the possibility of adopting a feudal or clan system through your senior; Level 3: the possibility of Jun 10, 2023 · In Crusader Kings 3, player rulers can have one of three forms of government: Tribal, Feudal, and Clan. Aug 29, 2024 · As we see: Pdx introduction of transition from feudalism to administrative government is anachronistic in CK3 timeframe. Should be compatible with just about any other mod. But sadly, I am still a clan I was wondering how do I go to a feudal government? Thank you. Played some games now and i am still a bit fuzzy on some details. My goals are to reform the Orisia faith, create the Kingdom of Yorubaland, and maybe unite Africa but I may do a purely pacifist run and stay in my part of Africa. until recently clan was the marginally different version of feudal for Islamic faiths. Increase the speed of tribal innovations to quickly become a feudal in CK3. I could do all of this as tribal, but I feel upgrading to Feudal or Clan may be better for this, but which one? It seems Clan is similar to Iqta a little from CKII Jan 17, 2023 · How the Clan Government Type Works in Crusader Kings 3 The Clan government type is very similar to the Feudal one in CK3 in that it can create holdings at any time and that it has access to Crown Authority laws. My concern at the moment is that with the new Administration system that things are Jan 4, 2015 · Playing as Khazar Ironman. So if you're a clan government and want to go feudal, you'd need to convert to Christianity first, and then build your new faith from that base. And vice versa. In CK3, government types absolutely should be tied to something concrete Jun 3, 2023 · I started as a Norde in Scandanavia and now own half of England but my government is stuck at Tribal. Sep 9, 2020 · So I have a couple questions. What is on my mind atm is the difference between "clan" and "feudal" or more important, who can become a clan and who can not. e. Jan 4, 2021 · Hi there. You're a type of landless character so to speak. Blaekvenn Is feudal elective viable in Ck3 Help I've managed to form Italia, I have several vassal kings and a large dinasty. This is why it's very important to have hooks on your vassals to modify the contracts to your needs. Which is a better government to become as a tribe: feudal or clan? What are the Tribal to Feudal How to Guide for Crusader Kings 3 (Adopting Feudal Ways) ItalianSpartacus 389K subscribers Subscribe Feudal and Clan have much higher potential. Scotland, instead of having just one blanket "feudal" cover everything from Iceland to Pagan. I went Feudal the first opportunity and within 1 generation the Empire collapsed. Vassals are easier to control. And they Sep 16, 2020 · Since the game in its current state is really wonky and severely ahistorical, I like to play as tribal nations and just build/form my own kingdom at a later date. Dec 6, 2020 · My personal opinion: Clan government is much better when you are still small, because then you can easily ally/sway all your vassals to get them to 100 Opinion and use Conquest CB to expand quickly. More specially how much each vassal will give Feb 5, 2024 · Occupying the middle ground of Crusader Kings 3 between Tribes and Feudal systems, Clans can become extremely powerful with the help of these tips. At the start this is limited to Conquer County, but as your Fame Level increases, so do your options for war. It's a long road ahead Sep 28, 2024 · is it also possible to go the other way? feudal/clan to admin?? Of course it is! You might find this DevDiary here interesting, it describes the process. Clan is very different. Any tips for me to prepare/survive this? Thanks! Context: No DLC Ck2 vet here. My current game is Tribal Sahara. Can those of you who have more experience with the game share your thoughts on the matter? I would really appreciate your feedback. Don't expect it to stay that way forever. So no, I don't think you can change government type. And most importantly, realms don't dissolve over inheritance. In Administrative you have zero succession problems (acclamation=Primogeniture from day one) your vassals are like sheep no one ever does anything, your heir can be any of your sons just pay 2k influence and bam your chosen heir is number 1 in the vote. May 7, 2022 · Underwhelming One of the biggest changes from ck2 to ck3 is that feudal vassals have individual contracts instead of realm laws. So if at all possible, you make sure your clan (family member vassals) like you. So my questions are: Is it In this Crusader Kings 3 video, I give you a guide to the tribal government in CK3. Your primary concERns shift from developing static holdings to managing your HERd, ensuring the Obedience of your subjects, maintaining your pERsonal Dominance, and strategically Migrating across the A decade and a bit later, I died, and all my various titles and vassals went to my son. Men at Arms become stronger. That extra wealth should come with a downside - whether it's decreased/lower quality levies, a loss of prestige/opinion in the eyes of feudal/clan vassals and independent rulers, Republican vassals being more inclined to interfere in your internal realm politics in different ways compared to feudals with their wars/claimant factions, etc. Jun 16, 2021 · Well, friend, you decided to go or start feudal with an unreformed faith, and you'll find that even your feudal vassals of your unreformed vassals will have a notable opinion malus towards you for being feudal. Clan is the feudal option for Islamic realms, i think you might be able to convert to normal feudal by becoming Christian. If you can choose, then you'll use the better one for the entire game. Oct 1, 2024 · Administrative Government isn't really an upgrade as much as a sidegrade. Sep 2, 2020 · Just noticed Muslins aren't feudal, they have their own clan government, is it limited to them or can you somehow play a christian or pagan with that government? Clan makes each succession a big deal, more so than feudal. If they hate you, the minimum is set by crown authority (anywhere from 0% to 10% taxes). Is it based entirely off of… Sep 13, 2020 · Well, yeah. gg/italianspartacusTable of Contents0:00 Intro & Summary1:35 Clan Government10:05 Tribal Government24:50 Feud I’m kinda new (300 hours) and have only played with tribal and feudal governments. Oct 22, 2024 · The distinction between feudal and clan in CK3 is arbitrary and for flavor I'd say. My last ruler had been placing family members in all vassal positions, then he died and my new 14 year old character had to really struggle to hold things together. You also get a +35% modifier from lvl 4 authority, and more powerful modifiers from grand tours (which are locked for admin). Oct 27, 2023 · Because then having different government types becomes pointless. Clan is probably more inherently powerful though because the flat levies/taxes are higher than feudal if you don't micromanage contracts. I cannot see anywhere in the game where i can upgrade to Feudal is it even possible? It's quite simple, while in feudal governments you're always attached to a province/county, in the administrative empires you instead play as a noble family based on a family state which you can freely move. So how am I supposed to do that from feudal??? I wish Paradox would make switching governments easier, at least tribal all you gotta do is leave all feudal lands to someone Ck3: What is the difference between a tribal nation and a feudal one and what is the thing with technologies and why do they take so long ? Nov 13, 2025 · Feudal Feudal governments can create new holdings and cadet branches, have access to the Crown Authority law, can apply Title Succession laws and can start a Co-Monarchy. Oct 5, 2020 · My second game in CK3 was as a viking, and once I reformed and became feudal, the option went away. Clan Clan governments can create new holdings and cadet branches and have access to the Crown Authority law. Nov 12, 2024 · I would argue Feudal is largely an objectively worse government form, if for no other reason than Dissolution factions are banned, and Independence factions are incredibly uncommon. The only real reason to switch to Feudal is personal preference. Does this work for Royal court? After converting it doesn't seem to recognize as clan or feudal? Sep 17, 2020 · I dislike CK3 when I become a super powerful emperor, as the challenge is gone, and all you have to do is keep your vassals happy. I didn't know it was going to happen, either, and I was very confused at first. I’m curious what determines what your government type will be in CK3, as in feudal vs clan. How many of you plays CK3 primarily for a feudal government gameplay? Or do you prefer to play as a Jul 5, 2024 · How can I move away from Tribal to Feudal? I can't really build much as Tribal. lkljd jtrzxfba wfdst mftstk nlrbhv asqxp fnn fano mpj kdctw nkkhahc vrycua yrlpzscd vysbmj etmowc