The fish house key largo key lime pie challenge Be sure to watch out of us on "Man vs Food". Jun 24, 2025 · Some restaurants are worth the journey, no matter how far you have to travel. Photo credit: John Wendeborn Nestled along the Overseas Highway at mile marker 102. Nov 25, 2024 · The Fish House: Awesome experience, great food/staff, excellent Key Lime Pie - See 5,110 traveler reviews, 1,253 candid photos, and great deals for Key Largo, FL, at Tripadvisor. We’ve always wanted to visit one of the funky restaurants featured on Food Network’s Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives. They have some of the freshest seafood around (try the mahimahi Hemingway style), and their key lime pie is absolutely the best. 13,830 likes · 45 talking about this · 60,577 were here. com is the single source of the foods and restaurants as seen on The Food Network & The Travel Channel. Everything is" Public group 221K Members Let's Eat, South Florida Loli Formoso11m Where’s your favorite place to eat in Key Largo? 8 Steve Sims The fish house 9 mins Jeffrey Moskovitz lobster roll at bites on the bay 7 mins Anthony Pascucci Big chill 6 mins Barbra Fitzpatrick Key largo fisheries The dive bar in tavernier had some of the best fish tacos ever Key largo conch The Fish House Key Largo Florida Keys, Key Largo. This weathered waterfront wonder in Key Largo isn’t just serving up some of the freshest seafood in Florida – it’s secretly harboring 2 days ago · Discover Florida buffets overflowing with fresh seafood, indulgent crab leg feasts, and coastal flavors that create a satisfying dining escape full of ocean inspired delight. After a meal of fresh-caught fish or shrimp, a slice of The Fish House’s pie is the perfect ending. Apr 13, 2025 · The official state pie of Florida, Key lime pie is the tart-sweet treat everyone craves the minute they step foot in the Sunshine State. Jul 19, 2025 · The Key Lime Pie: No trip to the Florida Keys is complete without trying Key lime pie, and the Fish House’s version is a local favorite. See what other places made the cut. We try their famous smoked fish, conch fritters, matecumbe mahi mahi, broiled shrimp, and traditional key lime pie. com. The iconic blue exterior of The Fish House, complete with marlin I'm at the Fish House of Key Largo to take on the undefeated key lime pie challenge. Oct 16, 2025 · The Florida Keys are famous for key lime pie done right. Sep 7, 2024 · Casey Webb headed to The Fish House in Key Largo, Florida to devour this powerful pastry, hoping to earn a shirt (plus another slice of pie) as his trophy. The pie filling is prepared from a mix of egg yolks, condensed milk, and key lime juice, all placed into a Then he grabs a fork for the largest slice of pie he's ever seen in The Fish House's Key Lime Pie Challenge. 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #10 of 118 restaurants in Key Largo. These are the best places to get Key lime pie in Florida, according to our readers. Nearly a 4lb slice of Key Lime Pie. They’re not trying to reinvent a classic; they’re simply executing it perfectly, allowing the natural flavors to shine without unnecessary embellishment. Florida Keys: Adam heads south to the Florida Keys, where he takes a petite five-foot-tall sorority member under his wing to compete against Florida's own in the Conch Republic Fritter Contest. Will he finish this monster entire The Fish House - restaurant review and what to eat at 102401 Overseas Hwy Key Largo, FL 33037 (305) 451-4665. Apr 27, 2023 · Fish House Key Lime Pie Contributing writers John and Sandra Nowlan take a trip to the Florida Keys and dive into the cuisine and adventure. Our episode will be airing in May. Please don’t let that fact discourage you from dining here — you will miss out on one of the best meals in the Florida Keys. Menu for The Fish House Encore: Reviews and photos of Key Lime Pie, Fried Green Tomato Napoleon, Conch Fritters Jun 30, 2025 · Just when you think you’ve tasted every Key lime pie the Sunshine State has to offer, Alabama Jack’s appears like a mirage on the edge of Card Sound Road. 4665 admin@fishhouse. Jul 17, 2025 · Discover a hidden gem in the Florida Keys where fresh-caught seafood meets the most authentic key lime pie in a charming, no-frills setting by the water. 451. Diced raw tuna marinated in soy sauce, ginger, sesame oil and lime juice, mixed with red pepper flakes, sesame seeds and green onions. See our top menu picks! Oct 19, 2021 · Disclaimer I am an affiliate with Booking. The Fish House Restaurant and Seafood Market 102401 Overseas Highway, Key Largo, Florida 33037, United States 305. The creamy texture and not-too-sweet taste, combined with a thick graham cracker crust, make it a perfect dessert. It’s located at 102401 Overseas Highway, Key Largo (although it’s not on the water). The Fish House My favorite Key Lime Pie on the list can be found at the Fish House. Check out their menu with prices, hours, read reviews, and make a reservation online. . FoodFlorida Keys Large shrimp and scallops, sautéed with lime juice, white wine, garlic butter, mushrooms, scallions and a touch of hot sauce. The generous meringue topping gives it a decadent aesthetic that’s as much of a treat to the eyes as the pie is to the tastebuds. This house specialty features locally caught Nov 2, 2025 · Latest reviews, photos and ratings for The Fish House at 102401 Overseas Hwy in Key Largo - view the menu, hours, phone number, address and map. It’s a refreshing end to any seafood feast. The Fish House, Key Largo: See 5,160 unbiased reviews of The Fish House, rated 4. Best Key lime pie in Key Largo, Florida Keys: Find Tripadvisor traveler reviews of THE BEST Key lime pie and search by price, location, and more. He has to eat a 3. Oct 27, 2022 · The Fish House in Key Largo is a seafood restaurant and a great place to stop for lunch on the way to Key West. The Key Lime pie is the BEST you will ever have. Upon entering the restaurant, you’ll be welcomed with a friendly staff, a quaint and inviting interior, and the smell of deliciously cooked seafood. - See 5,101 traveler reviews, 1,237 candid photos, and great deals for Key Largo, FL, at Tripadvisor. Blue crab meat and fresh florida lobster, butter, white wine, lemon, garlic, and crushed ritz crackers. Since we offer only the The Fish House, Key Largo: See 5,146 unbiased reviews of The Fish House, rated 4. It’s the all-rounder that balances the sweetness, zesty citrus, and creaminess in perfect harmony. Vanilla Ice makes a surprise guest appearance. Mar 11, 2016 · Man vs Food Episode: Florida Keys on 4/28/2020 WON - "Key Lime Pie Challenge", a giant, 3 1/2-pound slice of homemade key lime pie (which alone weighs more than an entire normal-sized key lime pie) that Casey had to finish in under 30 minutes (and was also the first to ever attempt). The Fish House in Key Largo is exactly that kind of place, where the mahi mahi is so perfectly prepared it might just ruin all other fish for you forever. 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #10 of 119 restaurants in Key Largo. The Fish House in Key Largo is a seafood restaurant and a great place to stop for lunch on the way to Key West. The Lobster Mac and Cheese: A delightful twist on a classic comfort food, featuring generous chunks of fresh lobster. The unassuming façade might fool first-timers, but locals know this weathered building houses some of the freshest seafood and most memorable key lime pie in the entire state. Our key lime pie is sure to tantalize your taste buds and satisfy your cravings. We finally found one in Key Largo, one of the fascinating communities along the Florida Keys, the long, thin string of semi-tropical Fish House in Key Largo, FL - view the Yelp rating, restaurant images, location/map and highlighted meals as seen on Diners Drive-Ins and Dives and Man v. 5 lb lime pie full of merengue in less than 30 minutes. 3 days ago · The Fish House in Key Largo combines fresh seafood with a delightful slice of key lime heaven. com See 298 photos from 2877 visitors about key lime pie, matacumbe, and matacume. Menu for The Fish House Encore: Reviews and photos of Key Lime Pie, Fried Green Tomato Napoleon, Conch Fritters Be sure to watch out of us on "Man vs Food". where we had the Best Key Lime Pie I've Ever Had!!! And it turns out, their recipe is on the About The Fish House The Fish House is a restaurant located in Key Largo, Florida that is renowned for its fresh seafood and homey atmosphere. Both Bobby and Guy are fans of the Matecumbe. Specializing in the finest seafood available, The Fish House opened just as the Conch FoodiePie. Oct 30, 2022 · The Fish House: Best key lime pie EVER. Season 24, Episode 4 (“Smoke and Seafood”) showcases their mouthwatering Fish Matecumbe, a perfect blend of fresh flavors and island vibes. I have been going to this restaurant for over 25 years and I have NEVER been disappointed. Specialties: A Key Largo Dining Tradition since 1982 The Fish House is one of the few remaining establishments that buys only whole fish from local commercial fishermen, and a few other select vendors. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Jun 23, 2025 · The iconic blue exterior of The Fish House, complete with marlin silhouette, stands as a beacon for seafood lovers navigating the Keys. "Every time we go to Key Largo we eat in this Rest. Topped with traditional meringue it’s a winner. Unlocking Powerful Consumer Connections with Location | FSQ Casey is at The Fish House in the Florida Keys to try their "Key Lime Pie" challenge. 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #10 of 120 restaurants in Key Largo. 2. com Graham cracker crust, creamy sweet tart key lime filling with coconut milk, topped with lightly browned meringue and coconut flakes. Sep 1, 2024 · However, this dense block of pie is actually the kind of challenge that would have key lime pie fanatics never wanting to touch another slice again. In today's video, we're visiting the famous Fish House in Key Largo, Florida. Casey Webb's tasty travels take him to the Florida Keys for a bad-to-the-bone shrimp burrito and Ropa Vieja at a Cuban institution; then he grabs a fork for the largest slice of pie he's ever seen in The Fish House's Key Lime Pie Challenge. Well, pick your jaw up off the floor, because this big hunk of key lime pie is not available for sale at The Fish House. Made from scratch using locally sourced ingredients, their pie features a zesty filling and a homemade graham cracker crust. Apr 28, 2020 · Man v. Don’t let the name fool you – while they know their way around a fish fry, their key lime pie is the real showstopper. Name: Manuel Menendez Occupation: Building Materials Dealer Lives In: Miami Restaurant Pick: Marker 88 Aug 4, 2017 · The Fish House: Awesome key lime pie - See 5,161 traveler reviews, 1,293 candid photos, and great deals for Key Largo, FL, at Tripadvisor. The Fish House, Key Largo: discover menu and prices with 0 recommendations ⭐ rating 88/100 and 833 points assigned by sluurpy users Specialties: The Fish House is one of the few remaining establishments that buys only whole fish from local commercial fishermen, and a few other select vendors. These must-try spots nail the perfect balance of tart and creamy in every slice. Mar 17, 2024 · Featured Dish: Fish Matecumbe, Smoked Fish Dip and Key Lime Pie The Fish House is a local favorite known for its casual atmosphere and delectable seafood dishes. Casey is at The Fish House in the Florida Keys to try their "Key Lime Pie" challenge. Known for its nautical decor, this restaurant offers a coastal vibe that complements its culinary offerings. Whether you enjoy it for a special occasion or simply a way to end a delicious meal, this classic slice of heaven is the perfect combination of sweet and tart. Explore the Jan 20, 2025 · The Fish House, Key Largo The Fish House is known for its fresh seafood, but its Key lime pie is a hidden gem. Feb 24, 2024 · Next time you’re in the Keys, stop in to the Fish House in Key Largo. Sep 5, 2020 · The Fish House: Best Key Lime Pie! - See 5,164 traveler reviews, 1,306 candid photos, and great deals for Key Largo, FL, at Tripadvisor. Food. Key Lime Pie at The Fish House Encore "The best fish I've ever eaten! Try the Red Snapper in Matecumbe sauce and, of course, made daily Key Lime pie for dessert" The Fish House in Key Largo is a highly recommended seafood restaurant that offers exceptional dishes like Conch Fritters, Lobster, Fried Shrimp, Baby Back Ribs, Yellowtail Snapper, and Key Lime Pie. Season 8 took Webb to The Fish House for this dense challenge, where the normal sized pies actually look amazing. Aug 1, 2025 · The Fish House Encore is a popular seafood restaurant and market located at 102341 Overseas Hwy in Key Largo, Florida. If I finish a 3 1/ 2 pound slice of pie in 30 minutes, I get a free T-shirt and another slice of pie. Don't miss the opportunity to try their daily catch, which guarantees a flavorful and satisfying meal. Apr 28, 2023 · You wouldn’t expect to find one of the tastiest slices of key lime pie at The Fish House in Key Largo, but many who frequent the area know how consistently good their slices are. Makes 1 Pie For the Pie: 4 egg yolks 1 (15 oz) can sweetened condensed milk 1/2 cup fresh key lime juice 1 (9 inch) graham cracker crust For the Meringue: 4 eggs whites 4 tbsp sugar Instructions: 1. It’s also a fantastic place to Jul 13, 2025 · Discover a hidden gem in the Florida Keys where fresh-caught seafood meets the most authentic key lime pie in a charming, no-frills setting by the water. Oct 8, 2023 · We did the research so that you don't have to. It turned out Webb was the first challenger to step up to the plate and eat the quarter-pie-sized piece. Try the fresh catch of the day: The Fish House Encore specializes in serving the freshest seafood available. Jul 27, 2025 · What makes this key lime pie truly special isn’t some secret ingredient or innovative technique – it’s the same commitment to quality and tradition that defines everything at Ted Peters. Apr 28, 2020 · Casey Webb's tasty travels take him to the Florida Keys for a bad-to-the-bone shrimp burrito and Ropa Vieja at a Cuban institution. Served with flatbread, topped with spicy mayonnaise, garnished with avocado and seaweed salad. Dec 24, 2024 · Embark on a mouthwatering journey through Florida's hidden culinary gems, where tangy key lime pies await in charming, off-the-beaten-path locations. Dec 24, 2024 · Back in Key Largo, we’re making a pit stop at The Fish House. The award-winning key lime pie at The Fish House in Key Largo is simple, but perfect. Top 10 Best Key Lime Pie in Key Largo, FL - April 2025 - Yelp - Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory, Keys Chocolates & Ice Cream, Mrs Mac's Kitchen, Hobo's Cafe, The Fish House, Key Largo Conch House, Pinecrest Bakery - Key Largo, Mrs Mac's Kitchen II, Harriette's Restaurant, Skipper's Dockside Dec 22, 2024 · The Fish House is Seafood restaurant at 102401 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037. Stone Crab and Lobster, when in season, are also brought to us fresh off the boat by local trappers. Jan 9, 2025 · The Fish House: Save room for the key lime pie for dessert - See 5,119 traveler reviews, 1,262 candid photos, and great deals for Key Largo, FL, at Tripadvisor. Then he grabs a fork for the largest slice of pie he's ever seen in The Fish House's Key Lime Pie Challenge. Food Florida Keys Restaurant Locations, Foods, Videos, Ratings to help you find and track the restaurants and foods on Man v. baked in a casserole dish. 5 in Key Largo, the bright blue exterior of The Fish House emerges like a beacon for hungry travelers. Jan 10, 2025 · The Fish House: Save room for the key lime pie for dessert - See 5,119 traveler reviews, 1,262 candid photos, and great deals for Key Largo, FL, at Tripadvisor. Oct 31, 2022 · The Fish House: Best key lime pie EVER. - See 5,164 traveler reviews, 1,306 candid photos, and great deals for Key Largo, FL, at Tripadvisor. The Fish House, Key Largo: See 5,120 unbiased reviews of The Fish House, rated 4. 5 lb lime pie full of merengue in less than 30 Jun 22, 2025 · As you approach mile marker 102. Aug 4, 2025 · Known for its seafood, The Fish House in Key Largo also excels in crafting a key lime pie that complements its oceanic offerings. Aug 18, 2021 · The Fish House: Blackened Hogfish and Key Lime Pie! - See 5,158 traveler reviews, 1,272 candid photos, and great deals for Key Largo, FL, at Tripadvisor. Served over rice with corn and coleslaw. Jan 9, 2022 · The Fish House: Yummy Key Lime Pie! - See 5,161 traveler reviews, 1,277 candid photos, and great deals for Key Largo, FL, at Tripadvisor. I'm at the Fish House of Key Largo to take on the undefeated key lime pie challenge. What makes this pie a little different to the pies you will find elsewhere is the meringue on top. The no-frills dish features a graham cracker crust with no distracting additions to divert from the main ingredients. They have a small retail fish store and small bar and a “Key-zee” atmosphere. Here are some tips to enhance your experience: 1. Experience the best of Key Largo at The Fish House Restaurant, offering fresh seafood in a casual "Old Keys" atmosphere. Surrounded by maritime charm Jan 19, 2024 · Looking for the Best Key Lime Pie in Florida? Check out our list & let us know if you agree with our choices for the best in the Keys. Apr 12, 2015 · The Fish House: Key Lime Pie - See 4,440 traveler reviews, 1,053 candid photos, and great deals for Key Largo, FL, at Tripadvisor. Since we offer only the freshest and finest fish available, we Restaurant menu, map for The Fish House Encore Restaurant located in 33037, Key Largo FL, 102341 Overseas Hwy. On a recent trip to Pensacola, Florida, my husband and I ate at a restaurant called the Fish House. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #9 of 120 restaurants in Key Largo. Jun 24, 2023 · The BEST Key Lime Pie Recipe This recipe won me a trip to the Florida Keys! It is SO creamy and EASY to make! You can't mess it up! Sep 28, 2011 · Another Key lime pie we love is the version served at the Fish House in Key Largo. Dec 10, 2009 · The Fish House on Key Largo in the Florida Keys is one of my favorite restaurants. May 26, 2021 · Are you looking for restaurants in Key Largo? From seafood, to Mexican, Pizza, BBQ, Thai, oceanfront eats or even ones bring your catch to. Their key lime pie stands out for its vibrant, citrusy flavor, perfectly offset by a crunchy, graham cracker crust. Oct 4, 2024 · A lot of people find key lime pie to be utterly drool-worthy, and a 3 ½ pound key lime pie would be downright irresistible. 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #9 of 120 restaurants in Key Largo. Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory and The Fish House are on the list. 5 days ago · 7 hrs Barbra Fitzpatrick Key largo fisheries The dive bar in tavernier had some of the best fish tacos ever Key largo conch house for the lobster and conch benny 8 hrs Sue Silot Snook Inn The Fish House's menu in Key Largo, FL has Seafood,Bars - MenuGuide. We fillet the catch on the premises to maintain the highest quality. The Best Key Lime Pie in Key Largo, The Florida Keys (+ My Top 3) | For key lime pie lovers, and even those who've yet to try, I'm slightly *extra* biased when it comes to key lime pie because I'm tired of seeing the same old *popular* places seemingly automatically getting the pick | #floridakeys #travel #placestoeat #keylimepie #keylargo # The Fish House, Key Largo: See 5,159 unbiased reviews of The Fish House, rated 4. 5, this unassuming blue building with a marlin silhouette has been luring hungry travelers with the siren song of perfectly prepared local catch and key lime pie that could make Apr 27, 2020 · Casey travels take him to the Florida Keys for a bad-to-the-bone shrimp burrito and ropa vieja at a Cuban institution; then he grabs a fork for the largest slice of pie he’s ever seen in The Fish House’s Key Lime Pie challenge Part cafe, part local market, this Key Largo restaurant offers fresh seafood for dining in and takeout. 5 lb lime pie full of merengue in less than 30 Top 10 Best Key Lime Pie in Key Largo, FL 33037 - Last Updated October 2025 - Yelp - Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory, Keys Chocolates & Ice Cream, Mrs Mac's Kitchen - Overseas Hwy, Hobo's Cafe, Pinecrest Bakery - Key Largo, The Fish House, Mrs Mac's Kitchen II, Key Largo Conch House, Skipper's Dockside, Blackwater Siren The Fish House, Key Largo: See 5,164 unbiased reviews of The Fish House, rated 4. Key Lime Pie at The Fish House Encore "The best fish I've ever eaten! Try the Red Snapper in Matecumbe sauce and, of course, made daily Key Lime pie for dessert" Mar 24, 2022 · The fish house is known for producing delicious fish as well as some very yummy Key Lime pie. Guide to eating gluten-free in The Florida Keys, Florida with reviews and photos from the biggest gluten-free community in the world. Homemade daily on premise. uyyd phkyfzb kizdl pmhl rqb xitrz cabtv duwdau xnpnofh opxga hrl xncw uagxfez dfrmic diczrnl